I picked up this audiobook on sale. I was a bit leery of a contemporary Megan Derr novel, but I thought I'd give it a try. My verdict is nope - only fantasy from this author from now on. I am starting to think I should just not read contemporary at all unless I have a very good reason.
I think The Missing Butterfly is supposed to be a modern day fairy tale of the Cinderfella sort, without any magic. Everyone is gorgeous and talented, and several are very rich (I could see more books in this series being set up the entire time I was listening). Lots of wish fulfillment for the deserving young MC. But for me it was all frosting and no cake - no suspense or real plot or antagonist to be found.
One thing that bothered me: the women characters came in exactly two flavors - the giggly gossipers who are way too involved in the male characters' love lives, and the horrible bitches. I know Megan Derr can write good female characters, but not this time.
The characters were all pretty two-dimensional. I don't mind that so much in fantasy, because they have interesting talents that come out in scary situations, and that keeps my attention. (Of course three-dimensional characters and an interesting plot is ideal, but you usually can't have everything).
Lots of people love this, so I might be casting some residual book slump shade on this book. I suspect people who like fluffy rock star stories would have fun (though there isn't much actually rock star activity in the book).